• Don't want to see ads? Install an adblocker like uBlock Origin or use a Europe-based privacy-friendly browser like Vivaldi or Mullvad.

Search results

  1. Vitruvius

    Debate Alexander the Great vs Julius Caesar: Who was the Greatest Commander in the Ancient World?

    I fully agree. The degree of corruption in the late republic cannot be understated. The senatorial class had been pushing the broader Italian farmer population into poverty through the latifundiae system which had supplemented middle class farming labor with slaves. We can debate the ethnic...
  2. Vitruvius

    Debate Alexander the Great vs Julius Caesar: Who was the Greatest Commander in the Ancient World?

    During Caesar's era horse mounted Roman archers whose role was copied from the Parthians were being developed and trained. They were termed the Sagitarii and were used with great success just 50 years after Gaius Julius Caesar's death in Germanicus' conquest of the Cherusci + allied Germanics...
  3. Vitruvius

    MBA to Classical/Early Roman era Mainland Greeks PCA

    Interesting take, but do we have evidence to support the idea that northern Greek coastal settlements will be closer to the Crete/dodecanese genetic structure? I'm not saying you're necessarily wrong, but this is simply new information to me.
  4. Vitruvius

    Genetic affinities between an ancient Greek colony and its metropolis: the case of 2 Amvrakia in western Greece

    And what specific Anatolian and Mycenaean samples are being used to quantify that 40-45% statement?
  5. Vitruvius

    Genetic affinities between an ancient Greek colony and its metropolis: the case of 2 Amvrakia in western Greece

    No, they likely had very little Mycenaean blood. It's hard to quantify it as it depends entirely on where said immigrants came from in Anatolia (it was a cline just like any other major deomgraphic hub), but if we use Isparta as an example, it's likely less than 15% Mycenaean influence...
  6. Vitruvius

    MBA to Classical/Early Roman era Mainland Greeks PCA

    A few thoughts: The north macedonia samples are from paeonia, not historic Greek Macedonia. Paeonians are likely good analogues for what actual Macedonians and other closely related northern Greeks resembled autosomally, however, so I think this assumptive label is reasonable. I also think...
  7. Vitruvius

    MBA to Classical/Early Roman era Mainland Greeks PCA

    This seems to line up with what Skourtanioti et al. reported; Anatolian dominant influence in the islands and Balkan influence in the mainland during the Bronze age; the Mycenaean population was being pulled both ways. It would appear that as time went on the Anatolian influence increased and...
  8. Vitruvius

    Genetic affinities between an ancient Greek colony and its metropolis: the case of 2 Amvrakia in western Greece

    Thanks for this PCA. The Tenea late Hellenistic clustering with central Italians is of particular interest. This individual may ultimately be from somewhere more northerly in Greece.
  9. Vitruvius

    Ethnic groups of Southeast Europe

    Interesting to see that just East Thrace alone has a higher population than the entire nation of Greece.
  10. Vitruvius

    Italian HO populations Divided by Province (SmartPCA)

    Yes and this is just another part of the background nuance that most people lack. There was not a hard ethnic separation between mainland Greeks and Western Anatolians by the Greek Dark ages. They were understood to be the same ethnic group even if we now know their genes were not totally...
  11. Vitruvius

    Genetic affinities between an ancient Greek colony and its metropolis: the case of 2 Amvrakia in western Greece

    Those who have been paying attention to the data will already know this. Anatolia clearly had a massive population with a high fertility rate from the Neolithic through at least the Iron age. Its only major admixture event prior to the Turks was with the Caucasus during the transition from...
  12. Vitruvius

    Genetic study The POPGEN project: building a French reference panel of genomes

    Yes, and Marseille is part of South-Eastern France. Also, genetic distance to modern Tuscans is being used as simply an arbitrary reference population chosen to represent central Italians - not some sort of documentation of direct contribution or admixture from Tuscany (which I think is...
  13. Vitruvius

    Genetic study The POPGEN project: building a French reference panel of genomes

    It is well known that Marseille was founded as the ancient Greek colony of Massalia which is why I mention both. It's probably impossible to quantify how much contribution from each at this stage.
  14. Vitruvius

    Genetic study The POPGEN project: building a French reference panel of genomes

    Yes, good catch on my mistake. The 1768 (not 1786) treaty of Versailles is what I was referring to.
  15. Vitruvius

    Italian HO populations Divided by Province (SmartPCA)

    As with all things, the less knowledgable will place their focus on binary results, attempting to oversimplify history into a predetermined framework which it does not match. The reality of the ethnological history of Italy is functionally no different than the history any other major european...
  16. Vitruvius

    Italian HO populations Divided by Province (SmartPCA)

    You already know this but I've been long advocating that the vast majority of the genome of southern Italy to be a result of Magna Graecian input with perhaps some further augmentation from later Imperial era Greek sources from both Anatolia, Peloponnesian Greece and their adjacent islands. I...
  17. Vitruvius

    Genetic study The POPGEN project: building a French reference panel of genomes

    I think in Southern France the overlap we are seeing are the clear results of colonization from Greek and Italian populations in the ancient and modern era. Cities like Nice (previously Nizza) used to be vastly majority ethnically Italian cities until even very recently. This phenomenon is...
  18. Vitruvius

    Italian HO populations Divided by Province (SmartPCA)

    Do you have any thoughts as to why the Northern Latium sample has such a strong EEF pull relative to the rest of Central Italy? Perhaps someone with recent Sardinian ancestry?
  19. Vitruvius

    Interesting FST outputs (aDNA Target vs Moderns)

    It's rather difficult to believe N. Italians, Spanish and Bulgarians being closer related to Norwegian Vikings than Finnish.
Back
Top