Recent content by Ghurier

Your comments are still very vague ... not a very good indication. Still, I have to congratulate you, in roughly 15 minutes you managed to review my 100+ papers (including 26 first-author/coresponding-author publications). Sadly, you failed to identify that my topic of study wasn't "celestial...

Thank you for your return, can you provide me your qualifications justifying that you pose as being able to "evaluate" the "scientific merit" of a claim ? Up to now, you failed to produce any relevant contribution, and you just dodged a request to elaborate on your claim ... which is very...

If you want ... any argument ? Because like that, it sounds like an unsubstanciated claim. Regarding my intellectual faculties ... google my name if you want to have a glimpse ! I'm very open to discuss ideas if you can propose something a bit more elaborated than an insult. If you can...

Indeed, with the new data is sounds even better. But I'm fairly sure you don't see why, isn't it ? Let me explain it to you ! In fact, the sample(s) you speak about (don't forget the Greek one, he is also very interesting per-se) change very little things to my best fitting model : Caucasus -->...

Not only, Denisovan/Neanderthal introgressions are also identified at the SNP level. Per-se, I have nothing to "imagine", that's not how science works. Thinking that there is an "ancient DNA mafia" shaking on its fundation because of few randoms on a forum is ... how to say that politely ...

While it is clear that all moderators weren't acting that way ... Anthrogenica had serious troubles on this side. Yet, GenArchivist was providing a way better moderation with less ideological bias (which might annoy some people in fact). F-stats are very minimal basic tools, what would be the...

Ready for another Hallstatt-gate ? Would you accept Tuscan-eneolitic samples when they will pop-up ? Because last time, you tried very weird stuff, I still didn't got your reasoning about the lack of sample in France that would make samples in Germany disapear ??? That's clearly next-level...

Already back ? You are aware that Hajji-Firuz is just a little bit further on the same cline you are looking at ? LSE_o work very well with Maykop-like as source too. I will repeat it, in this area of the world, around that time ... you can nearly make pass anything. There is just no peculiar...

Still ZO1002 with HajjiFiruz_C-like population pass as an alternative model. The connection between Caucasus and Tuscany Eneolitic around 3500 BCE is published-work in peer-reviewed journals. Feel free to publish your results and analysis in peer-reviewed journals, I will gladly read what you...

Because I'm nice, and you likely failed to find this results :

HajjiFiruz_C ? Look at the graph you posted, you may find the connection. You can make it work with Aknashen if you want ... you can make work nearly anything in that part of the world at this time. You have 4 deeply divergent components merging together in various fraction ... but no peculier...

J-Z615 in Mokrin is ~1100 years appart from its TMRCA with the lineages who ended in Sardinia. While you have no issue to morph Nuragic samples in ~few centuries ... I think you can easily understand why the consideration you bring here are irrelevant. You are just trying to solve a case ~1000...

That's a big question about timing and how many "lineages" could be carried successfully by a small infiltration group. Probably, the easiest version is to have J-Z622 being a lonely injector, and then diversifying in-situ around Tuscany. Still, a movement injecting multiple lineage is not out...

Not really, it is not because one lineage of J-L283 ended in the Yamnayan that all lineages ended there. Bascially, Iran-N influenced India and Europe. For J-M241, you have two clades that have taken separated road. Here, you are just facing the same situation, one ended in Usatovo and later...

Not that much when you know how it works ... PCA is just reducing dimentionality of the problem, whereas QPadm technically conserves the whole genetic distances. But a tailored PCA is as efficient as a QPadm approach (if the problem is concerning a sufficiently small geographical region...