Recent content by Archetype0ne

All of this methods have caveats. Autosomally speaking: Only fstats would come close to being useful. PCA methods would really struggle to have any epistemological value. I will take the case of Albanians to make a point that can be made of all populations, since that's the population I have...

We more or less agree. Hence why my first sentence was "When it comes to ancient Greeks, one needs to first define what they mean by this.". If we mean Minoans or Myceneans continuity, that is on the lower end as the region was central to many empires and we know the population movements are a...

Anatolia in BA/IA had a number of different peoples inhabiting it. When it comes to ancient Greeks, one needs to first define what they mean by this. From what we can tell J-Y13128 was within these early Greek populations, but what haplogroup is responsible for the IE aspect of the Greek...

I think Peladhi was Bektashi indeed, at least my side of the family certainly was. About the Y, here on eupedia the person did not. Over at old anthrogenica I can not find the messages anymore, since the forum went down. @Granzon You should write to XDRES here.

Damn Pleadhi be representing on Fora quite heavily. That makes 4 of us now. For a village with like couple of houses nowadays seems like we are overrepresented :D

Hi Granzon are you the same as XDRES? Another user I talked to some time ago with paternals from Peladhi?

Hi cousin. Best reach out to Hunter Provyn at https://phylogeographer.com/about-me/ (end of the page has his email).

I would say quite the opposite. All the samples we have found from the Illyrian territory so far range overwhelmingly between J2-L283 and R1b-m269. Across the board those two haplogroup are the biggest contributors to Albanian paternal clades. If anything this puts wind in the sails to how...

Okay, so help me understand, Bell Beakers in Ancient Greece and India? Because the root not only seems Proto-Indo-European, but the Proto-Indo-European connections links the abovementioned regions (India, Ancient Greece, Albania etc). Meanwhile the current consensus (See Lazaridis et al 2022)...

Fair enough. So lets assume your reconstructions hold merit, which with linguistics its hard to tell due to sound changes. But by your logic Slavic "ogan" - fire, has nothing notably Slavic, because of Sanskrit and old Hindi "angi" - fire. For obvious reasons, historic, linguistic and...

Truth is we may never know. Thracian, Illyrian and Macedonian are very poorly attested. Yet on placename formation Albanian and Thracian are diametrically different, that is to say at the grammar level. Just like English is a Germanic language by virtue of Grammar despite ?70% of its lexicon...

I mean. On the one hand I went out of my way to provide you both genetic sources, and even improved the linguistic arguments to the current state of the art with post-2020 scientific papers. I am not sure if you understand what using sources means, but It seems not. On the other hand, you are...

Cinamak BA-IA Albania - Illyrii proprie dicti: R-PF7562 and R-Z2103: Cinamak EBA-IA Albania ~2000BC Kamenica BA Albania L283: MBA Albania ~ 1800BC Dalmatia - BA-IA Croatia - BA-IA Serbia- BA-IA Montenegro- MBA-IA L283 and Z2103 meanwhile are found also in Maros Serbia EBA as well as among...

And in what way are Albanians not descendent of Illyrians, if by the same metrics Italians are from the Romans? 35-40% of Albanians are split between R-M269 and L283. With the former present in Cinamak BA-IA Albania and Kamenica tumuli BA Albania, and the later being the overwhelming majority in...

Leaving aside the wording of your statement, which ofc Albanians are not Illyrians just like Italians are not Romans. What exactly convinced you?